All designs are funded! Thank you, backers. <3
Creatures of the Night Enamel Pin Collection

Creatures of the Night Enamel Pin Collection

This pin project was funded in 36 hours! Creatures, cats, and cryptids stalking in the night. Who knew they could be so creepy and cute at the same time?
$1,902 🎉
of $1,100 (USD) goal
Project Ended
Ended on




Copy Link

Pintopia 2024

This project is part of Pintopia 2024, which runs from March 28th - April 18th 2024. The more Pintopia pins you back, the more FREE pins you can earn ✨ Learn more →


Pin Designs

Our initial goal was funded within 36 hours of launch! Be sure to pledge for all the pins you want so we can unlock our stretch goals faster.

I wanted to make these pin designs unique, so every design has special effects. They all have glow in the dark details, and some have screen printing, pearlescent, and polarized details

 The Mothman, UFO, Jackalope, Raccoon, and Cactus Cat pins are all unlocked! Mothman, the Jackalope, the Raccoon, and the Cactus Cat will have glow in the dark eyes, and the UFO pin will have a glowing beam & alien with a pearlescent ship interior.

I Believe Pin Design

The I BELIEVE design will be 1.75" and the text will glow in the dark! It unlocks at $1,700.

Ghost Cat Freebie Collab Pin

The Ghost Cat pin is a FREEBIE that's only available to backers who pledge to both the Creatures project and the Cat Chaos project! This pin glows in the dark and I'm working with my manufacturer to see if we can get it to be polarized as well. It will be hauntingly beautiful.

Pin Details

◇ All pins are hard enamel
◇ Approx. 1.5"-1.75" on the longest edge, depending on the design
◇ All pins have silver plating
◇ Includes back posts with rubber backings
◇ Includes official Barely Scary back stamp logo
◇ Will come packaged on backing cards

Add-on Items

Feel free to add these on to your pledge now! First, pick your initial pledge, then select how many add-ons you would like. If you forget, or want to add on to your pledge later, that's cool! You'll be able to do that when you finish your survey after the project ends.

Enamel Pins

Feel free to add-on extra pins to your pledge! (See the Pin Design section for more pin information!)

Bumper Stickers
I Brake for Cryptids Bumper Sticker

The Brake for Cryptids Bumper Sticker will be available in both black and yellow at about 8.5"x2.5". You'll get to choose your preference while completing the survey at the end of the project.

Barely Scary Logo Button

This button design will be about 1.25" and is a freebie to anyone who pledges for a pin during the first 48 hrs of the campaign. It is also available as an add-on if you pledge after the first 48 hrs, or if you want additional buttons!

Mini Pins
Mini Star and Bat Pins

The Mini Star and Mini Bat pins will be restocked thanks to this campaign! These were originally from the Mystical Campaign that we had on Kickstarter. They are available to add-on to your pledge in packs of 3. The Mini Bats have black nickel plating, and the stars have gold plating and glow in the dark!


Add on a lanyard to your pledge! These were originally created during the Mystical Campaign. The Lunar lanyard comes in standard and wrist length. The Batty lanyard is available as standard length.

Mystery B-Grade Pins
Mystery B-Grade Pins

Select this add-on to get a mystery pin with your pledge! It will be selected out of the designs we get unlocked.

Pintopia 2024

Welcome to Pintopia — a celebration of creativity and collaboration from a diverse group of artists collectively running enamel pin crowdfunding projects from March 28th - April 18th.

Freebie Cross-Collaboration Pins — All 125+ Pintopia creators have paired up with a fellow participant to create two unique pin designs together. If BOTH projects reach their initial funding goal, backers who support BOTH will get the TWO [2] cross-collab pins for FREE! One from each creator. The more pairs of Pintopia creators you support, the more free pins you will earn ✨

Cross-collab Pin Designs

This is the logo of Imagination Cats
Pledge to Barely Scary's & Imagination Cats' projects to get both freebie collab pins!


Join us on the journey to discover the unknown...

Hello! Let me start by introducing myself. My name is Traci and I started Barely Scary in 2020. I have had 3 successful crowdfunding campaigns in the past, and it looks like this will be my 4th!

I've always been fascinated by the unknown. Creatures and cryptids instill me with a sense of curiosity and creativity. This project will bring forth truth and knowledge about these creatures.

Your pledge and contributions to this journey will change the world! However, this journey is not without risk...

There is a high likelihood these creatures will be unleashed into the world... Perhaps, even into your own home...

Thank you so much for supporting this project!! Every pledge and share helps. <3 

How this project works

  •  Backerkit is an all-or-nothing crowdfunding platform, which means you be charged for your pledge at the end of the campaign ONLY if we reach our goal. If we don't reach the goal, you won't be charged. Pledge now, pay later.  
  • Is there a design you like that isn't unlocked? Pledge anyway to help the project move forward! Pledging for locked designs helps get them unlocked sooner.
  • Any pledge that is for 2+ pins is discounted! When you make a pledge, you are receiving the product at a lower price. Once the campaign ends, the pins will be sold for $12/ea. on my website.
  • Once the Backerkit project ends, it will process your card and hold the funds for two weeks to make sure everything runs smoothly. Then I can submit my order to create the pins!!
  • Help unlock every design by pledging for every pin you want! For example, if you really want a locked pin design, please pledge for it so we can reach our goal faster!

 If you have any additional questions, feel free to send me an email! [email protected] 


All shipping fees will be charged separately AFTER the campaign. The prices below are estimates, so keep in mind they may be different. Actual shipping prices will be determined based on the weight of the order. Also, if you add-on additional items, your shipping cost may increase.

Estimated shipping costs (for 3 pins):

  • $5.00 USA
  • $18.00 Canada
  • $22.00 Australia, NZ, Ireland, Norway

Unfortunately, I am not able to ship to every country. If you are in the UK or EU, please read below for more information.

EU & UK Customers

Due to shipping restrictions, EU & UK customers must pledge though Etsy, here

Etsy will deal with VAT & IOSS, so it will make the pledging process easier for everyone involved!
If you believe that this project is not in compliance with BackerKit’s Community Guidelines or Terms of Service, you can file a report by sending a message via this link: Report this project
Cross Collab Project

Back both collaborator projects to earn free pins from both creators. View Collaborator →